Halloween Horror: Wildcats Embarrassed in Pine Bluff 63-21

Credits: UAPB Athletics

I normally wait until Sunday evening to write my article, just to be sure I’ve had a chance to fully digest the gameday experience. But I can’t wait that long tonight. I need to get this out of my system on this Halloween Evening so here goes…

Who were those ghosts and goblins dressed in Bethune-Cookman uniforms on Saturday afternoon?

Seriously, I know it was Halloween, but ain’t no way that was the same team that beat Alabama State in early October.

I kept waiting for the Wildcats to show up. I kept waiting for somebody to make a play, find some fight, or give us some indication that the team we watched take down Jackson State just a week ago was still in there somewhere.

But they never came.

Instead, we watched a Bethune team that looked completely unrecognizable. The energy wasn’t there. The execution wasn’t there. The fight certainly wasn’t there. Whatever confidence and momentum the Wildcats carried out of their October victories seemed to disappear somewhere between Daytona Beach and Pine Bluff.

This was a full blown Halloween horror show as Arkansas-Pine Bluff handed the Wildcats a humiliating 63-21 defeat, and the nightmare began almost as soon as the game kicked off.

Jaylen Jennings took the first snap from scrimmage 87 yards to give UAPB a 7-0 lead.

Eight seconds later, freshman quarterback Joel Morris took the field getting the start in place of the injured Tyler Jefferson. Morris threw an interception on BCU’s first offensive play.

Pine Bluff converted that turnover into a touchdown in 2 plays covering 22 yards in 22 seconds; 14-0.

On BCU’s next offensive drive, they ran the ball on first down, followed by another Morris interception which was returned for a touchdown on second down. Pine Bluff 21, BCU 0 less than 2 minutes into the game.

You heard that right. 21-0 in under 2 minutes.

The comedy of errors continued in the first half with Pine Bluff scoring 14 more points off of two more BCU interceptions. They added a 6th score to take a 42-0 lead into halftime.

Embarrassing!

By night’s end, UAPB racked up 333 yards rushing and 451 yards of offense.

Meanwhile BCU was held under their season average rushing for 166 yards. They also failed to reach the 200 yard passing mark and have yet to throw for 200 yards in any game this season.

At some point, we have to stop treating these performances like isolated incidents.

To put it bluntly, the road struggles under Raymond Woodie are becoming impossible to ignore. Heck, they are becoming worrisome.

Bethune is now 2-11 in SWAC road games during the Woodie era. Across those 13 games, BCU has been outscored 420–256. The only road victories have come against Mississippi Valley State, which the Wildcats defeated in both 2024 and 2026.

That’s not a small sample size anymore. That’s a pattern. A troubling pattern because you can’t play all your games at home.

What is happening with this program on the road? And why does this team struggle so mightily to carry its success from one week into the next? Are there systematic issues that need to be addressed beyond the usual conversations about fundamentals and attention to detail?

These are legitimate questions, and Saturday only added fuel to them.

The Identity Crisis Continues

Wildcat supporters throughout this season have repeatedly stated they simply don’t know which team is going to show up.

And here we are, nine games into the season, still having the same conversation.

Think about the emotional roller coaster in October alone; BCU has had two signature wins at home against ASU and JSU as mentioned earlier; but they have also had two blowout road losses over these last four weeks against AAMU and now UAPB.

Here is the hard truth, we know exactly who the Wildcats are. They are a 5-4 team sitting one game above .500. They are good enough to beat anyone, but also vulnerable enough to lose to anyone.

That’s not criticism. It’s what the results tell us 3/4ths of the way through the season.

The Clock Is Still Ticking

For all the disappointment, the season isn’t over.

BCU still has three games remaining against three HBCU Bluebloods (Southern, Grambling, Florida A&M). The Wildcats need to win two of those games to secure its first winning season since 2019.

If the Wildcats win all three, they would end the year 8-4 with wins over ASU, JSU, Southern, Grambling, and FAMU.

That would be a pretty impressive year. But you can’t win three if you don’t win the first one.

The first one just so happens to be on the road to face Southern in Baton Rouge. And if Saturday wasn’t frightening enough, Southern just delivered a statement of its own by blowing the doors off Florida A&M 42-14.

The Jaguars appear to be finding their stride at exactly the wrong time for the Wildcats.

Halloween is over. And so is the margin for error if the Wildcats want to change the narrative surrounding this program.

Saturday was ugly. There’s no dressing it up, and no pretending it didn’t happen.

The questions aren’t going away. The only way to quiet them is to answer them on the field.

Put Pine Bluff behind you. Regroup. Refocus. Get back to work. Finish strong.

November is waiting.

We Got The Finish – Wildcats Take Down Jackson State 24-21 in Battle for 1st Place

Heading into the 2026 football season, there was a popular thought circulating around HBCU football circles. That thought was Bethune-Cookman might have a little something to say about who wins the SWAC East.

The thinking was that the Wildcats could play spoiler to one of the division’s preseason favorites, Alabama State or Jackson State.

Well, the Wildcats handled Alabama State in early October. And there they stood Saturday afternoon in Daytona Beach, trailing defending SWAC East champion Jackson State 21-17, facing 3rd-and-11 from the Tigers’ 19-yardline with under a minute remaining.

Quarterback Tyler Jefferson took the snap and looked left. First read wasn’t there. He stepped up in the pocket. Nothing. Jefferson scrambled right, buying just enough time to spot Rickie Shaw working his way across the field.

Shaw found a sliver of daylight in the right corner of the end zone.

TOUCHDOWN WILDCATS!

Bethune-Cookman 24. Jackson State 21.

Forty seconds remaining.

Pandemonium swept through the stadium as Shaw celebrated with his Kappa Alpha Psi shimmy!

Rickie Shaw Game Winning 19 YD TD

But for a few of us, there was no pandemonium. Not yet.

We’ve been here before.

You know, this close to a win only to watch it slip through your fingers in the most agonizing fashion.

So while the stadium erupted, a few of us suspended our excitement and began an almost ritualistic chant:

“WE GOT TO FINISH! WE GOT TO FINISH!”

Heck, Athletic Director Reggie Theus was standing in that same end zone where Shaw had just scored. Amid the celebration, he looked me squarely in the eyes and said the exact same thing.

“We got to finish.”

Jackson State took the ensuing possession and marched into field goal range with six ticks remaining.

Here we go again.

But something funny happened.

The winds that had seemingly calmed down from the earlier downpour picked up almost on cue, blowing toward the left of the uprights.

Good snap.

Good hold.

Good contact.

But Andrew Ivaniciuc’s 49-yard attempt sailed left as time expired.

WILDCATS WIN!

What an ending.

What. A. Game.

And just like that, Bethune had knocked off the defending SWAC East champions, 24-21, and moved into a tie for first place in the division.

The Wildcats found a way to finish.

Was it a perfect game? Absolutely not. But that’s kinda what’s encouraging about this win. BCU left plenty opportunities on the field. But they were able to overcome their own mistakes, and STILL take down the Tigers. That says an awful lot about where Coach Raymond Woodie has this program right now.

The question now is was Saturday simply a big win, or was it an announcement?

You know, the kind of victory that shifts not just the momentum of a season, but the trajectory of a program.

DEFENSE, DEFENSE, AND MORE DEFENSE

As dramatic as Jefferson’s game winning touchdown pass was, the real story Saturday was Bethune’s suffocating defense.

The Wildcats slowed down Jackson State’s vaunted rushing attack and controlled their offense as a whole.

Consider these numbers from BCU’s defense

  • held JSU to 33 rushing yards on 36 attempts.
  • 13-of-28 passing, under 50 percent.
  • 10 tackles for loss.
  • 4 sacks.
  • 1 forced fumble.

Pure dominance.

Stephen Sparrow was everywhere, collecting 11 tackles, a sack, and two tackles for loss.

Isaiah Washburn wasn’t far behind, recording seven tackles, a sack, and three tackles for loss.

The Wildcats pressured, pressured, and pressured the Tigers bringing 5 or 6 defenders on seemingly 90% of the snaps.

Offensively, Jefferson once again showed why his emergence has been one of the more intriguing developments of this season.

A week after providing the spark against Mississippi Valley State, Jefferson delivered three touchdown passes against Jackson State.

A 21-yarder to Josh Evans.

A 33-yarder to Rashon Brown.

And, of course, the 19-yard game winner to Rickie Shaw.

Jefferson hasn’t solved every issue with Bethune’s passing game. But he’s demonstrating a knack for making big plays when the Wildcats need them most. Plus he is a huge asset in the running game.

A LITTLE HISTORY LESSON

Here’s something you probably wouldn’t know unless you’re a football nerd like me.

Before BCU entered the SWAC, the Wildcats actually held a slightly better all-time historical winning percentage than Jackson State.

Heading into the 2020 season, the historical records looked like this:

Think about that for a moment.

For all the deserved attention JSU has has received throughout the years, Bethune-Cookman has its own rich football tradition.

But since joining the SWAC, the programs have traveled vastly different roads.

JSU has been one of the conference’s standard bearers, collecting SWAC championships and national attention.

Meanwhile, BCU has been fighting to rediscover the winning tradition that once made the Wildcats one of the most respected programs in HBCU football.

And that’s why Saturday mattered.

Not simply because Bethune beat Jackson State.

But because Jackson State represents the level BCU is trying to get back to.

The question surrounding this program has been whether the Wildcats could once again compete consistently with the SWAC’s best.

Well, on Saturday, they didn’t just compete. They won.

NOW COMES THE FUN PART

Let’s see how the Wildcats handle success.

But something about this victory and their recent play tells me they will.

Maybe it’s the way the defense has developed into one of the conference’s most disruptive units.

Maybe it’s Jefferson’s emergence.

Or perhaps it’s the growing confidence of a team that is beginning to believe it belongs in the championship conversation.

Will this be the catalyst that returns the Wildcats to the ranks of year in and year out contenders?

We don’t know that yet.

But we do know this: The Wildcats are contenders RIGHT NOW.

THE PATH FORWARD

The most straightforward path to the SWAC East crown is simple enough.

Win out and hope Alabama A&M drops a game.

If that happens, Bethune wins the East.

There are other potential scenarios, but with several weeks of football remaining, it’s far too early to start untangling every possible tiebreaker.

The Wildcats have more immediate concerns.

Get healthy.

Stay focused.

And take care of business against Arkansas-Pine Bluff this weekend.

Saturday was a huge win. Perhaps the biggest of the Raymond Woodie era.

But if this team wants to turn a signature victory into a championship season, it has to embrace the very words that echoed through the stadium during those final 40 seconds.

WE GOT TO FINISH.

Gameday Photos Against JSU