Saturday’s visit to Baton Rouge began with the Wildcats fighting for first place in the SWAC East. It ended with another disappointing chapter in what has become a recurring nightmare on the road.
Southern ran through BCU, handing the Wildcats a 45-17 defeat at A.W. Mumford Stadium and sending them home with more questions than answers.
The Jaguars rushed for 381 yards, averaged nearly nine yards per carry and found the end zone with little resistance for much of the afternoon.
It was another lopsided result, but perhaps the most concerning aspect of the loss isn’t necessarily what happened Saturday; it’s what these road performances continue to reveal about the football program.
The Wildcats are running out of healthy bodies, their passing game has struggled to provide a consistent alternative to the running game, and their lack of depth is becoming increasingly difficult to conceal.
The road isn’t creating these problems. It’s exposing them.
Injuries Are Taking Their Toll. Depth Is Becoming the Bigger Story.
There is a temptation to look at Saturday’s result and conclude that BCU simply wasn’t ready to compete. But that’s not the whole story.
The Wildcats are running out of healthy bodies.
Five offensive linemen who have started games for Bethune were unavailable. The defensive front has also been depleted, with multiple guys unavailable to the coaching staff. Quarterback Tyler Jefferson returned to the lineup, but clearly wasn’t operating at full strength.
None of this is an excuse for the results. Every team is dealing with injuries this time of year. But the ability to absorb those injuries is what’s proving to be difficult for BCU.
The Road Keeps Exposing the Warts
At some point, you run out of different ways to describe BCU’s road problem.
Different opponents. Different stadiums. Same disappointing result.
And this isn’t simply about winning and losing. It’s about the manner in which some of these defeats have occurred.
In their three SWAC road losses, Bethune has given up 163 points while scoring just 55. That’s an average game score of about 54-18. Ouch!
Opponents Have Figured Out the Formula
Bethune has been pretty good running the ball and ranks 3rd in the conference in rushing. The Wildcats have been less dynamic through the air ranking last in the conference passing.
The old adage is points come from the passing game. And this seems to be the case for Cookman. They average just 21.5 points per game against SWAC opponents, including three performances of 17 points or fewer.
The passing game has struggled to provide the kind of consistent production necessary to keep defenses honest.
That’s particularly problematic when the running game is the foundation of the offense. If opponents can commit numbers to stopping the run without consistently paying a price through the air, the offensive playbook becomes increasingly predictable.
The situation has only become more difficult with the injuries along the offensive line and with Jefferson’s injury limitations.
Against Southern, Jefferson finished with 144 passing yards, one touchdown and an interception. He added 20 yards rushing, but the Wildcats managed only 290 yards of total offense.
It’s a difficult combination to overcome. The Wildcats need the running game to establish their offensive identity, but they also need a passing attack capable of punishing defenses that sell out to stop it.
Right now, they haven’t shown enough consistency with this balance.
The Defense Has Its Own Problems
Southern rushed for 381 yards Saturday, led by Trey Holly’s 206 yards and two touchdowns. Macario Dade added another 104 yards on just four carries, including a 70-yard touchdown run.
This comes a week after UAPB rushed for over 300 yards on the Wildcats.
Those numbers are difficult to explain away. But they clearly point to why this team has fallen on tough times the past two weeks
Two Games Remain. The Wildcats Still Have Something to Play For.
Despite the disappointment of the last two Saturdays, the season isn’t over.
Bethune-Cookman enters the final stretch at 5-5, with remaining games against Grambling and Florida A&M.
The Wildcats need to win both games to improve upon last season’s 6-6 record and secure the first winning season of the Raymond Woodie Jr. era.
That’s not an insignificant accomplishment.
A winning record would represent tangible progress in a program still working to establish its footing in the SWAC.
Thankfully neither of those contests are on the road. GSU visits Daytona Stadium this weekend where Bethune has won 8 straight SWAC home games.
Let’s hope our guys can keep it up and finish the season strong.
I normally wait until Sunday evening to write my article, just to be sure I’ve had a chance to fully digest the gameday experience. But I can’t wait that long tonight. I need to get this out of my system on this Halloween Evening so here goes…
Who were those ghosts and goblins dressed in Bethune-Cookman uniforms on Saturday afternoon?
Seriously, I know it was Halloween, but ain’t no way that was the same team that beat Alabama State in early October.
I kept waiting for the Wildcats to show up. I kept waiting for somebody to make a play, find some fight, or give us some indication that the team we watched take down Jackson State just a week ago was still in there somewhere.
But they never came.
Instead, we watched a Bethune team that looked completely unrecognizable. The energy wasn’t there. The execution wasn’t there. The fight certainly wasn’t there. Whatever confidence and momentum the Wildcats carried out of their October victories seemed to disappear somewhere between Daytona Beach and Pine Bluff.
This was a full blown Halloween horror show as Arkansas-Pine Bluff handed the Wildcats a humiliating 63-21 defeat, and the nightmare began almost as soon as the game kicked off.
Jaylen Jennings took the first snap from scrimmage 87 yards to give UAPB a 7-0 lead.
Eight seconds later, freshman quarterback Joel Morris took the field getting the start in place of the injured Tyler Jefferson. Morris threw an interception on BCU’s first offensive play.
Pine Bluff converted that turnover into a touchdown in 2 plays covering 22 yards in 22 seconds; 14-0.
On BCU’s next offensive drive, they ran the ball on first down, followed by another Morris interception which was returned for a touchdown on second down. Pine Bluff 21, BCU 0 less than 2 minutes into the game.
You heard that right. 21-0 in under 2 minutes.
The comedy of errors continued in the first half with Pine Bluff scoring 14 more points off of two more BCU interceptions. They added a 6th score to take a 42-0 lead into halftime.
Embarrassing!
By night’s end, UAPB racked up 333 yards rushing and 451 yards of offense.
Meanwhile BCU was held under their season average rushing for 166 yards. They also failed to reach the 200 yard passing mark and have yet to throw for 200 yards in any game this season.
At some point, we have to stop treating these performances like isolated incidents.
To put it bluntly, the road struggles under Raymond Woodie are becoming impossible to ignore. Heck, they are becoming worrisome.
Bethune is now 2-11 in SWAC road games during the Woodie era. Across those 13 games, BCU has been outscored 420–256. The only road victories have come against Mississippi Valley State, which the Wildcats defeated in both 2024 and 2026.
That’s not a small sample size anymore. That’s a pattern. A troubling pattern because you can’t play all your games at home.
What is happening with this program on the road? And why does this team struggle so mightily to carry its success from one week into the next? Are there systematic issues that need to be addressed beyond the usual conversations about fundamentals and attention to detail?
These are legitimate questions, and Saturday only added fuel to them.
The Identity Crisis Continues
Wildcat supporters throughout this season have repeatedly stated they simply don’t know which team is going to show up.
And here we are, nine games into the season, still having the same conversation.
Think about the emotional roller coaster in October alone; BCU has had two signature wins at home against ASU and JSU as mentioned earlier; but they have also had two blowout road losses over these last four weeks against AAMU and now UAPB.
Here is the hard truth, we know exactly who the Wildcats are. They are a 5-4 team sitting one game above .500. They are good enough to beat anyone, but also vulnerable enough to lose to anyone.
That’s not criticism. It’s what the results tell us 3/4ths of the way through the season.
The Clock Is Still Ticking
For all the disappointment, the season isn’t over.
BCU still has three games remaining against three HBCU Bluebloods (Southern, Grambling, Florida A&M). The Wildcats need to win two of those games to secure its first winning season since 2019.
If the Wildcats win all three, they would end the year 8-4 with wins over ASU, JSU, Southern, Grambling, and FAMU.
That would be a pretty impressive year. But you can’t win three if you don’t win the first one.
The first one just so happens to be on the road to face Southern in Baton Rouge. And if Saturday wasn’t frightening enough, Southern just delivered a statement of its own by blowing the doors off Florida A&M 42-14.
The Jaguars appear to be finding their stride at exactly the wrong time for the Wildcats.
Halloween is over. And so is the margin for error if the Wildcats want to change the narrative surrounding this program.
Saturday was ugly. There’s no dressing it up, and no pretending it didn’t happen.
The questions aren’t going away. The only way to quiet them is to answer them on the field.
Put Pine Bluff behind you. Regroup. Refocus. Get back to work. Finish strong.
It’s the Monday after the 2025 Florida Classic and I’m just now typing out this wrap-up. Not because I’m short on words or emotion. It’s the opposite. I’ve spent the last two days trying to sort through the highs, the lows, the despair, the delirium, the absolute emotional whiplash that this game dropped on all of us. I’m still not sure I’m ready to capture that roller coaster in writing, but here goes.
For the past decade, my wife and I have made it our business to bring someone new to the Florida Classic each year. It’s a personal ministry at this point despite the fact that our Bethune-Cookman Wildcats had dropped four in a row heading into Saturday’s game.
The Florida Classic(S), as some pronounce it, is one of the premier Black cultural events in the state of Florida. It just has to be experienced! From the trash talk within families, offices, churches, sororities and fraternities; to the food vendors lined up on Tampa Avenue. From the excellence of The Marching Wildcats and The Marching 100; to the barbs thrown at the other school at the luncheon the day prior to the game. It’s all amazing.
But as great as all of those things are, nothing…and I mean nothing tops a dramatic football moment in this extravaganza. On Saturday night we got all the dramatics we could handle.
There were four lead changes and thirty-two points scored in the fourth quarter alone. Punch. Counter punch. Kick. Counter kick. One moment you’re talking trash, the next you’re feeling like trash.
THE SWINGING OF EMOTIONS
BCU dominated the first half and took a 24–9 lead into halftime. Wildcat fans were floating higher than those seven hills we always hear about. But FAMU opened the second half with a touchdown to cut it to 24–16. Then came a pair of missed BCU field goals, followed by a made FAMU field goal to make it 24–19 with 8:51 left in the fourth quarter.
At this point, Wildcat fans were feeling tight. And I mean, tight-tight.
A quick BCU three-and-out opened the door, and FAMU kicked it in. One play later, a 72 yard Jamal Hailey run up the gut, felt like a kick in the gut. The two-point conversion was successful and suddenly the Rattlers were up 27–24. For the first time in probably a month, the thought occurred to me that Cookman might actually lose this ballgame.
I was flabbergasted. Shook. Nervous.
My wife and I’s first-time Classic guest asked, “what just happened?”
On the inside I was asking the same thing. But with clinched teeth and a tight stomach I uttered: “there’s still over 7 minutes left. A lot can happen.”
BON-BON LIGHTS UP THE NIGHT
BCU got the ball back and on 2nd and 5, with both bands blasting, something special happened. Timmy McClain hit Javon “Bon-Bon” Ross on a short crosser. Bon-Bon hit the brakes, reverse-pivoted, dropped two Rattlers flat to the ground, outran another, and raced 67 yards up the FAMU sideline directly towards their band for a highlight reel touchdown.
I exhaled 4-years worth of Classic stress in one breath. Surely, surely, that was enough excitement for the night and BCU had this game won right?
Nope. Not yet at least.
THE SWING… AGAIN
FAMU marched right back. On 3rd and 10 from the BCU 29, the defense came up with what looked like a massive stop. But a questionable holding call on CB Johnny Harris III extended the drive. One play later, Thad Franklin punched it in. Cats down 34–31 with 2:19 left.
I’d seen this movie. Twice this season— Grambling and Jackson State—similar situation, similar heartbreak. I told myself to accept the L. Five straight to FAMU? The dark clouds were rising.
The bands struck up again: The 100 playing “Hey Let’s Go,” the Marching Wildcats blasting “Vice Versa.”
Me? I was playing sad songs in my head.
Sack on first down against BCU.
My sad playlist turned into a depressed playlist.
Incomplete on 2nd and 20.
Stomach now in my socks and I am speaking in strange tongues trying to keep it all together.
On 3rd and 20, McClain found Rickie Shaw for 17 yards—just enough to make 4th down manageable. The Cats converted and hope reentered my body.
THE MOMENT THAT CHANGED EVERYTHING
Fifty-five seconds later: 4th and 8 from the FAMU 41.
A first down puts you in field goal range. No first down and it’s over. Simple math.
McClain drops back. The safe throw is there. He passes it up. He looks deep… and he finds a WIDE OPEN Josh Evans streaking untouched down the BCU sideline.
Our first-time guest was crying. Offensive Coordinator Donte Pimpleton was crying. Half the stadium was crying—some from heartbreak, some from pure joy. Depends on which colors you were rocking.
THE LOCAL KIDS WHO OWNED THE MOMENT
McClain and Evans—two Central Florida Area kids transferred to BCU to be closer to home. Playing in front of their people; in the biggest game of the year; they are now forever etched into the lore of this rivalry.
McClain called it “an out-of-body experience” in the postgame presser. No lie detected.
As for our guest? She rated it a 10 out of 10 experience. Said it was way better than advertised. Said she’ll be back every year.
That’s what this event is about. Abject agony for some; utter joy for others. Lasting memories for all.
The 2025 edition…An Instant Classic Florida Classic.
Qtr
Time
Scoring Play
FAM
BCU
1st
08:33
FAM – Porto,Daniel 45 yd field goal 7 plays, 36 yards, TOP 04:22
3
0
1st
04:38
BCU – Jenkins,Lorenzo 25 yd pass from McClain,Timmy (Dominguez,Juan kick) 7 plays, 61 yards, TOP 03:28
3
7
2nd
13:31
BCU – Dominguez,Juan 30 yd field goal 7 plays, 43 yards, TOP 03:38
3
10
2nd
06:52
BCU – Robinson,Khamani 50 yd run (Dominguez,Juan kick), 1 plays, 50 yards, TOP 00:10
3
17
2nd
04:04
FAM – Burris,Armand 44 yd pass from Johnson III,RJ ( ) 6 plays, 75 yards, TOP 02:48
9
17
2nd
00:23
BCU – Huggins,Maleek 7 yd pass from McClain,Timmy (Dominguez,Juan kick) 10 plays, 90 yards, TOP 03:33
9
24
3rd
11:56
FAM – Burris,Armand 17 yd pass from Johnson III,RJ (Porto,Daniel kick) 8 plays, 68 yards, TOP 02:58
16
24
4th
08:49
FAM – Porto,Daniel 37 yd field goal 10 plays, 62 yards, TOP 03:55
19
24
4th
07:47
FAM – Hailey,Jamal 72 yd run (Lawrence,Goldie pass), 1 plays, 72 yards, TOP 00:12
27
24
4th
07:03
BCU – Ross,Javon 67 yd pass from McClain,Timmy (Dominguez,Juan kick) 2 plays, 72 yards, TOP 00:36
27
31
4th
02:19
FAM – Franklin, Jr.,Thad 19 yd run (Porto,Daniel kick), 9 plays, 75 yards, TOP 04:43
34
31
4th
00:20
BCU – Evans,Josh 41 yd pass from McClain,Timmy (Dominguez,Juan kick) 8 plays, 70 yards, TOP 01:52
Daytona Stadium is starting to feel a little different these days. It’s a little louder, a little bit more lively, and dare I say it…filled with a lot more hope as Bethune-Cookman has strung together back-to-back home wins. The Wildcats are giving their fans something they haven’t truly experienced in years: a reason to believe.
Last week’s victory over Edward Waters felt more like relief. The same with last year’s home win over Grambling State. But Saturday’s win over Alabama A&M just felt different.
-That was an excellent football game against a good, well-coached A&M team.
-That was a game that sparked a lot of pride among the fans.
-That ladies and gentlemen was Wildcat football.
A Well-Played Game from Start to Finish
From the opening whistle, BCU looked sharp, well-prepared, and confident. They looked like a good football program to say it bluntly. They asserted themselves early and repeatedly against a quality SWAC opponent. They also showed just how far this squad has progressed since game one this season. Was it perfect? Nah, not even close but it was the kind of well-rounded performance that sets a tone for the weeks ahead.
When in doubt, give the ball to “Bon-Bon”
Sophomore receiver Javon “Bon-Bon” Ross had himself a game. The Deland native, nicknamed Bon-Bon by his grandmother, electrified the crowd with a breakout performance that was hard to ignore.
On the Wildcats’ very first offensive play, quarterback Cam Ransom uncorked a 79-yard bomb. It dropped perfectly into Ross’s hands and he did the rest by outrunning the defenders on his way to the endzone. On BCU’s next possession, Ross added a 41-yard touchdown run after taking a reverse to the house. Two touchdowns for Ross scored in two different ways. The fanbase now knows what the locals have known for a while…good things happen when you give the ball to Bon-Bon.
The Playmakers Keep Rising
Ross wasn’t the only local product shining on Saturday. True freshman running back Khamani Robinson continues to prove that the moment isn’t too big for him. Robinson scored BCU’s third touchdown on a 24 yard scamper giving the Cats the lead at halftime.
And then there’s Cam Ransom. Each week, he keeps getting better and right now, it’s hard to find any HBCU quarterback who is playing better. His command of the offense, his efficiency, and his growing chemistry with playmakers like Ross and Rickie Shaw, Maleek Huggins, Lorenzo Jenkins and others are changing the Wildcats’ offensive identity right before our eyes.
The Fans are Starting to Believe Too
Shoutout to the fans who showed up Saturday. The threat of rainstorms seemed to have kept a few people away. However, those who decided to attend were treated to a great HBCU experience. Not only did they witness BCU’s best overall performance in years, but they also enjoyed a SWAC Band Battle.
Daytona Stadium hosted an opposing SWAC band for the first time since BCU joined the conference. Alabama A&M’s Marching Maroon and White (MMW) made the trip to “Da Beach”. After speaking with many in attendance, the MMW headed back to Huntsville with a slew of new fans. The MMW are wecolmed back anytime.
BCU’s Marching Wildcats did what they always do…they “showed up and showed out”. Give AAMU’s band the edge in song selection and repertoire, but the Pride delivered in execution and overall sound quality. In the end, both bands represented well and it was the fans who were the biggest winners.
It was great seeing the vibe in the stands all game. The bands helped with the atmosphere and the weather held off for the most part, but it was about more than the good bands and decent weather. The fans were active, engaged, and for the first time in a long time, anxiety-free. Cookman fans regained a bit of their mojo. They actually expected something good to happen, rather than waiting on disaster. Even after the game, I heard from at least a dozen fans. They all echoed the same sentiment…this was the best they had felt after a BCU game in years.
The excitement was palpable and the hope was contagious. You could see it in the way the team responded to mistakes. They didn’t allow miscues to beat them twice. Instead, they corrected them and overcame them in real time.
You could see it in the way the fans cheered…a little louder and a little longer.
And most importantly, you saw it on the scoreboard; Wildcats 41, Bulldogs 34.
I like this feeling. Heck, we all like this feeling. And judging by the team’s growing confidence, we may get to share this feeling a little more often and that’s something we can get used to.
Statistic
AAM
BCU
First Downs
Total
22
25
Rushing
6
14
Passing
14
10
Penalty
2
1
Rushing
Total (Net)
125
259
Attempts
32
35
Avg. Per Rush
3.9
7.4
Rushing TDs
1
4
Yds. Gained
133
266
Yds. Lost
8
7
Passing
Total (Net)
355
257
Comp.-Att.-Int.
27–41-1
18-25-2
Avg. / Att.
8.7
10.3
Avg. / Comp.
13.1
14.3
TDs
3
2
Total Offense
Yards
480
516
Plays
73
60
Avg. / Play
6.6
8.6
Fumbles – Lost
1–1
0-0
Penalties – Yds.
4-50
6–61
Punting
Punts – Yds.
2-75
3–131
Avg. / Punt
37.5
43.7
Inside 20
1
0
50+ Yds.
0
1
Touchbacks
0
1
Fair Catch
0
0
Kickoffs
Total – Yds.
7-368
7-435
Avg. Yds. / Kickoff
52.6
62.1
Touchbacks
1
2
Returns
Punt: Total – Yds. – TDs
2–16-0
0-0-0
Punt: Avg. / Return
8.0
0
Kickoff: Total – Yds. – TDs
5-111-0
6-68-0
Kickoff: Avg. / Return
22.2
11.3
INT: Total – Yds. – TDs
2-0-0
1-0-0
Fumble: Total – Yds. – TDs
0-0-0
0-0-0
Miscellaneous
Misc. Yards
0
0
Poss. Time
31:59
28:01
3rd. Down Conv.
11 of 18
8 of 11
4th. Down Conversions
3 of 3
0 of 0
Red-Zone: Scores – Chances
3–3
1-1
Sacks: Total – Yds.
0-0
2–4
PAT: Total – Made
4-4
5–6
2PT Conversion: Total – Made
0-0
0-0
Field Goals: Total – Made
2–2
0-0
Qtr
Time
Scoring Play
AAM
BCU
1st
09:35
AAM – Faulk,David 45 yd field goal 11 plays, 53 yards, TOP 05:21
3
0
1st
09:20
BCU – Ross,Javon 79 yd pass from Ransom,Cam’Ron (Dominguez,Juan kick) 1 plays, 79 yards, TOP 00:11
3
7
1st
01:27
AAM – Nero,Kolton 2 yd run (Faulk,David kick), 4 plays, 62 yards, TOP 01:43
10
7
2nd
13:38
BCU – Ross,Javon 41 yd run (Dominguez,Juan kick), 7 plays, 83 yards, TOP 02:44
10
14
2nd
08:41
AAM – Pierre,Franck 72 yd pass from Handley,Eric (Faulk,David kick) 4 plays, 83 yards, TOP 01:10
17
14
2nd
01:18
BCU – Robinson,Khamani 24 yd run ( ), 14 plays, 83 yards, TOP 07:19
17
20
2nd
00:08
BCU – Shaw II,Rickie 27 yd pass from Ransom,Cam’Ron (Dominguez,Juan kick) 7 plays, 63 yards, TOP 00:54
17
27
3rd
11:31
AAM – Pierre,Franck 32 yd pass from Handley,Eric (Faulk,David kick) 3 plays, 58 yards, TOP 00:57
24
27
3rd
10:18
BCU – Scott Jr.,Alihaja 8 yd run (Dominguez,Juan kick), 3 plays, 69 yards, TOP 01:07
24
34
3rd
03:44
AAM – Abner,Travaunta 1 yd pass from Handley,Eric (Faulk,David kick) 12 plays, 59 yards, TOP 06:25
31
34
4th
05:58
AAM – Faulk,David 19 yd field goal 15 plays, 57 yards, TOP 06:44
34
34
4th
01:07
BCU – Scott Jr.,Alihaja 26 yd run (Dominguez,Juan kick), 8 plays, 66 yards, TOP 04:44
If you ask most HBCU fans to circle the big games this weekend, you’d be hard-pressed to find anyone pointing to Bethune-Cookman vs. South Carolina State. And honestly—why would they?
South Carolina State is the defending MEAC champ, sitting at 1-1 currently, and looking set to defend their crown. Bethune-Cookman, on the other hand, hasn’t factored into many meaningful contests recently and have been on the butt end of a couple of whoppings the past two weeks.
On paper, this looks like a mismatch. But call me crazy, something tells me this could be a sneaky good game this weekend.
call me crazy, something tells me this could be a sneaky good game this weekend.
J Bell – HailWildcats.com
Maybe that’s the Wildcat fanatic in me talking…Probably is.
Maybe I’m still holding on to the luster of yesteryear when the BCU vs SCSU matchup carried the intensity of a prizefight when the two were MEAC heavyweights.
Or maybe—just maybe—it’s because history says these two programs rarely give us a dud on the gridiron.
Series Split over last 10 games
The series is split at 5 wins and 5 losses apiece over the past 10 matchups. It’s split 11 wins and 9 losses in favor of the Bulldogs over the past 20.
So despite the difference in expectations for these squads, the back-and-forth series record shows you don’t sleep on this rivalry; even when the Wildcats look down.
What to Expect Saturday
Here is Coach Woodie and the Wildcats’ chance to make an announcement to the HBCU world; and SCSU is the perfect opponent to do it against. Don’t expect the same watered-down schemes we’ve seen through Weeks 1 and 2 against BCU’s FBS opponents.
On Defense: Expect more blitz packages, more disruption, and more variations in coverages.
On Offense: Look for much more tempo, more creativity, more quarterback run, and more getting the ball in the hands of the playmakers quickly.
I’m NOT predicting a BCU upset but that’s not out of the question either. What I am predicting is the type of Dog and Cat fight that has made this series very competitive.
J Bell – HailWildcats.com
Let me be clear, I’m NOT predicting a BCU upset but that’s not out of the question either. What I am predicting is the type of Dog and Cat fight that has made this series very competitive and my favorite on the field matchup for BCU. And who knows, if things break right…well, let’s just say if things break right, it will be hard to shut me up next week.
Yeah, I know I’m crazy. I know how that sounds. I guess I will see y’all in Orangeburg.
November Pressure Cooker: Why the Next Month Could Shape the Next Few Years of Bethune-Cookman Football
Bethune-Cookman football is entering a defining chapter, as November stands to be an evaluation and culture-shaping month that could impact the program for years to come.
The little private school on “Da Beach”, who thrives on overcoming obstacles and doing more with less, is facing one of the toughest stretches in its 101-year history of playing football. In fact, you would have to look back almost 40 years to find a low point even close to what Wildcat fans have witnessed over the past 4 seasons.
This article will try to highlight why the next four games represent not only an opportunity for redemption for the current coaching staff and squad; but a potential beachhead from which the Wildcats can launch as they attempt to ascend to the top of the mountain that is HBCU football.
A Historic Struggle with Consequences
The Wildcats are spiraling in one of the worst four-year runs that Bethune-Cookman football has ever endured and everyone feels the weight of this moment. The stakes are higher than ever for the coaching staff to chart a new course and improve on its 1-7 record.
A former Bethune-Cookman football player recently shared some valuable insight with me. He pointed out that this season’s lineup of games offers some uniquely relevant comparisons. BCU has played or will play 10 games this year against SWAC, FCS, and Division II competition. 8 of those 10 matchups will be against teams with first- or second-year head coaches. When you consider Coach Raymond Woodie Jr. is in his second year, it presents a fair basis for comparison to measure the development and progression of this year’s Bethune-Cookman team against those other squads with first and second year guys.
Reasonable conclusions can be drawn when you consider the shared realities between BCU and so much of its competition this season. To take it a step further, it would be irresponsible to not have reasonable expectations or hold this program accountable for their performances when the like for like comparisons are so abundant.
The Revenue Angle
Despite BCU’s lackluster on-field performance, the program isn’t operating without resources. Could things be better…well course. Could they be worse? That’s also true. But this current team has the luxury of a brand new on-campus artificial turf practice field. They have a new on-campus locker room. And they have access to the same on-campus grass practice field that Wesley Moore, Alvin Wyatt, and Brian Jenkins’ championship teams practiced on.
According to the July 1, 2022 – June 30, 2023 EADA report, BCU’s athletic department generated $13,636,502 in revenue. This figure is the fifth-highest in the SWAC and trailed only Southern, Alabama State, Alabama A&M, and Prairie View A&M during the same timeframe. The financial report at least suggests that there are enough raw resources to work with to be competitive.
This is especially true when comparing BCU to fellow SWAC programs like Jackson State ($12,821,652) and Florida A&M ($13,172,315), and even MEAC powerhouses like North Carolina Central ($11,339, 477) and South Carolina State ($13,271,355) —all of whom generated less revenue during the same timeframe but achieved better results on the field.
When analyzing Bethune-Cookman’s 2024 EADA, the overall department revenue dropped precipitously from the year prior. Football specific expenses dropped from $5,270,780 in 2023 to $4,683,961 in 2024 which represents an 11.13% decrease.
Despite the decrease in football expenses, BCU still outspent Jackson State ($2,867,733) by almost $2 million in 2024.
November to Remember: Head to Head Evaluations Against First-Year Head Coaches in the SWAC
Considering BCU Athletics’ revenue is commensurate with its SWAC counterparts, let’s rule out the lack of resources as a factor in the team’s ongoing struggles. Instead, we can turn our attention to the field and make evaluations based on a) how this team has looked so far this season; and b) how the guys in maroon and gold will close out the year against similarly suited teams given the fact that all four games in November are against SWAC foes with first year head coaches:
• Grambling State: Head Coach Mickey Joseph
• Southern: Head Coach Terrence Graves
• Texas Southern: Head Coach Cris Dishman
• Florida A&M: Head Coach James Colzie.
The indictment against the Wildcats heading into these four contests is that the first year guys at GSU (4-4), SU (4-4), TxSU (3-4), and FAMU (4-3) have all won multiple games and are all floating around .500.
Considering this, the logical question is why does Bethune only have one win to this point?
With each passing week, the doubts surrounding this coaching staff, this team, and this program will only grow more and more if the team continues to struggle to find success.
On the other hand, winning a few of these last games would do more than boost this year’s record; it would send a message that Bethune-Cookman can compete with programs under similar rebuilding timelines and lay a foundation for a culture of competitiveness for the future. Even a few close losses could help build the case for Coach Woodie and his staff.
Transfer Portal and Roster Revamp: A Double-Edged Sword
Another crucial aspect of BCU’s rebuilding process that’s under the microscope is its utilization of the transfer portal. With 24 transfers on the roster this season, Coach Woodie has tapped into the potential of the portal to expedite a roster overhaul. However, the lack of return on that investment raises questions: has this transfer infusion truly moved the needle, or are we still looking for players to buy into the program’s culture and vision? What’s a reasonable amount of time supporters should expect for players to create cohesion, a shared sense of purpose, and a belief that winning here is possible?
That brings us to a hard lesson from earlier this season: Division II Clark Atlanta, winless in 2023, came into Daytona under a first-year coach, Teddy Keaton, and they walked away with a victory. Clark now sits at 5-2-1, and are assured of a winning record. This moment should serve as both a wake-up call and a challenge for BCU: if Clark can build a winning culture in such a short period, Bethune-Cookman supporters have every reason to demand the same.
What Needs to Happen in the Next Four Games
So, what does BCU need to accomplish over the next month to steer the program toward a stronger future?
1. Competitive Performances: The Wildcats need to play these next four games with consistent intensity and execution. They can’t just play well for a play, or a series, or a quarter, or a half. Football is a 60 minute game so play well to the end.
Close games, even if they end in narrow losses, will show that the team is competitive and progressing. Blowouts, however, would be another setback and may undermine the confidence of players and fans alike.
2. Defensive Accountability: The Wildcats have given up a staggering amount of yardage this season and rank last in the conference in total defense (490 ypg). To frustrate matters, a huge part of playing well on defense is effort and intensity; and effort and intensity are not something you can have questioned as a football team. To stand a chance against these upcoming SWAC teams, and to begin to rewrite the narrative around this program, the defense must prioritize tackling, play with some passion, and limit explosive plays. Or as Coach Woodie often states: play with technique, fundamentals, and attention to detail.
3. Offensive Improvement: The Wildcats’ offense looked as good as it had all season this past Saturday in the first half of the Jackson State game. Build on that. Play that way for 4 quarters and the offense should be fine. Quarterback Luke Sprague, running back Dennis Palmer, and wide receiver Lorenze Jenkins have all shown flashes recently. All three skill players are eligible to return next season. Couple that with several freshmen offensive linemen who have made their way into the starting lineup and you’re starting to create a foundation for the future on offense.
4. Cultural Cohesion: A consistent challenge for programs in rebuild mode is achieving cultural buy-in from players, especially with so many new faces. The next four games should reveal whether the team has developed any resiliency and buy-in; or if there is more work to do in bringing this roster together.
5. Winning at Least Two Games: BCU needs to demonstrate progress with wins. Capturing at least two victories over the next four games would signal the Wildcats are building forward momentum. Coach Woodie led BCU to 3 wins in his first season so anything less has to be considered a failure. A couple of wins against these SWAC foes would resonate through recruiting pipelines, fan engagement, and player morale, setting the tone for next year.
Building for the future
These next few matchups are more than just a series of games—they are a critical moment to shape the program’s identity and trajectory for years to come. It is an honest opportunity to assess where BCU stands relative to programs dealing with similar realities. Now is the time for the Wildcats to demonstrate that they are capable of competing and winning consistently.
This November will be remembered. The question is will it be remembered as the month BCU football began its resurgence or as another missed opportunity and setback for the program. Let’s hope that we can look back and say it was the start of something great. The future of Bethune-Cookman football is now, and it’s time to seize it.
The only saving grace of this sweltering August heat is that it signifies the end of ‘Silly Season’. You know what Silly Season is right? It’s the time between the end of Spring football and the launch of the new season. It’s the time when the information void gets filled with guesswork, misguided enthusiasm and exaggerated claims of how good the home team will be; while the other squads are vilified and damned.
Let me phrase it this way. My high school football coach was also a hunting enthusiast. He would often say “when the tailgate drops, the bullspit stops”; except he didn’t say “spit” if you know what I mean. It became a rally call for us; kinda like that black hat that brother threw 20 feet in the air on a Montgomery Riverfront but I digress.
Here is what he meant by it.
On a typical hunting trip, the guys would load up a pickup truck with the dogs and essential equipment. They would share laughs and jokes along the way. The dogs were still treated like pets and extensions of the family. However, once they reached the hunting grounds, the atmosphere shifted. The laughter ceased and the dogs stopped being family pets and gave way to their primal instincts. Once the tailgate drops the guns, the boars, the untamed wilderness all become real.
King Robert Baratheon would have never been fatally injured by a boar and lost the Iron Throne had he embraced this principle more seriously.
I know college football isn’t exactly “Game of Thrones” but the point is still valid. The tailgate is just about ready to drop and it is time for the bullcrap to stop!
Once it does, all of the expert prognostications, star ratings, and preseason rankings won’t matter. The players who feel like they have been slept on, disrespected, and overlooked will soon have the opportunity to prove it outside of social media and on the gridiron. The stage is almost set for real games, with real opponents, and real consequences.
A glance at the SWAC landscape reveals a ton of unpredictability, not the least of which is a shortage of proven quarterbacks throughout the league. That’s not to say that there aren’t talented guys vying to be their squads’ top signal callers. There are plenty of talented players, including quarterbacks, in this league; but being proven and being talented are two completely different phenomenons. The real question is who can translate talent into performance. FAMU’s Jeremy Moussa and Texas Southern’s Andrew Body have proven their worth at the position. Everyone else is hoping that they have found their guy.
To muddy things up even more in the SWAC East, half of the division welcomes first year head coaches (BCU, JSU and MVSU); and all of the schools in the East added at least 20 new players through the transfer portal.
When you sum all of these things up, I think it is next to impossible to truly predict how this season is going to play out. About the only thing that I am willing to bet on is that the SWAC will be full of surprises. The good news is that in less than 30 days, questions will be answered the only place that really matters: ON THE FIELD.
Big Wins: 9/7 Furman (35-28), 9/14 at Eastern Kentucky (51-32) Bad Losses: 11/9 at Charleston Southern (26-31), 11/23 at South Carolina (10-70)
Strengths:
Coastal Carolina is paced on offense by stud running back Lorenzo Taliaferro. The Walter Payton Award Finalist has gained just under 1,500 rushing this season while accounting for 23 touchdowns on the ground. As a unit, the Coastal ground attack averages 283 yards per contest and ranks 3rd nationally in that department.
Quarterback Alex Ross may not be as elusive as last year’s signal caller Aramis Hillary but he seems to be more accurate delivering the ball. Add in the formidable pass catching trio of Matt Hazel, Niccolo Mastromatteo, and DeMario Bennett and it is easy to see why the Chants are 3rd in the nation in scoring offense averaging just over 42 points per game. Weaknesses:
Coastal’s defense has been less than stellar (at least statistically) for the duration of the season. CCU’s defense is allowing 435 yards per game to opponents including 210 yards on the ground. What’s difficult to determine is whether or not Coastal’s defensive statistics are an accurate reflection of the unit’s overall talent level or merely a consequence of their opponents having more opportunities considering the frequency at which the Chant offense scores.
Big Wins: 9/1 at Tennessee State (12-9), 9/14 Florida International (34-13), 10/26 South Carolina State (14-3) Bad Losses: 9/21 at Florida State (6-54), 11/9 Norfolk State (24-27)
Strengths:
The Wildcats get things done through the efforts of a dominating defense and a physical running game. Only Florida State scored more than 27 points on the Wildcat defense this season. BCU has held their opponents to 10 points or fewer in seven of their 12 games. Defensive ends LeBrandon Richardson and Dyron Dye are strong against the run and pass. Linebacker Jarkevis Fields is a tackling machine and defensive backs Nick Addison and Tim Burke are ball-hawks.
The Wildcats rank in the top ten nationally in total defense, scoring defense, and rushing offense. Isidore Jackson is the team’s top rusher. Cary White and Anthony Jordan are more physical, downhill runners who both see a ton of action and quarterbacks Quentin Williams and Jackie Wilson are also capable of making plays with their feet.
Weaknesses:
BCU is the most heavily penalized team in the country averaging 10.50 penalties per contest. Possessions and hidden yards are precious in postseason play meaning the Wildcats will need to find a way to limit un-timely penalties while still maintaining their aggressive style of play if they are to move on in the tournament.
Bethune’s passing game has all of the pieces needed to be successful but the air attack has sputtered at times this season. BCU quarterbacks have thrown more interceptions (12) than touchdowns (9) this year and the Wildcats have finished four games with less than 100 yards gained through the air. Ironically, BCU is 4-0 in games in which they pass for under 100 yards.
Norfolk, VA – Fourth-year head coach Brian Jenkins of Bethune-Cookman was selected for his third Coach of the Year honor. Jenkins led the Wildcats to a 7-1 MEAC mark and a 10-2 overall record. The Wildcats defeated Florida A&M, 29-10, to clinch a share of the conference’s regular season title and secure the MEAC’s automatic berth to the NCAA Division I (FCS) Championships. The Wildcats are currently ranked 12th in both the Sports Network’s FCS and FCS Coaches Poll. He has led Bethune-Cookman to three MEAC titles in four years and fell just one game shy of back-to-back undefeated MEAC finishes.
Howard quarterback Greg McGhee was selected as the Mid-Eastern Athletic Conference’s (MEAC) Offensive Player of the Year and Joe Thomas of South Carolina State earned the Defensive Player of the Year honors, as voted on by the MEAC’s head football coaches and sports information directors.
North Carolina A&T’s Tarik Cohen earned the Rookie of the Year award and Tristan Bellamy, of S.C. State, was selected as Offensive Lineman of the Year.
Junior Greg McGhee led the MEAC in total offense (272.9 avg./g) and ranked second in passing yards per game (198.2 avg./g). He completed 228 passes on 385 attempts (59%) with 16 touchdowns in 12 games this season. He also finished the season ranked third in the MEAC in rushing with 896 yards (74.7 avg./g), on 157 attempts, and three touchdowns. McGhee ranks 19th in the nation in total offense and 31st in completions per game (19). He earned conference Offensive Player of the Week accolades twice this season. McGhee is the tenth Bison to earn the conference’s Offensive Player of the Year honor and first since Ted White in 1996.
Joe Thomas recorded 116 total tackles, 84 solo, with a conference-best 19 tackles for a loss during the 2013 campaign. Thomas collected 7.5 sacks, sixth in the MEAC, with one interception, five breakups, five hurries, one forced fumble and one fumble recovery to help the Bulldogs finish as the nation’s No. 1 rushing defense (80.5 avg./g) and No. 2 scoring defense (14.0 avg./g). Thomas earned Defensive Player of the Week honors once this season and is currently listed on the Sports Network’s Buck Buchannan Award watch list, which recognizes the nation’s top Football Championship Subdivision (FCS) defensive player. Thomas becomes the 13th Bulldog to earn the conference’s top defensive award, however he is only the second to have been selected in more than 10 years (David Erby 2010).
As a freshman, North Carolina A&T’s Tarik Cohen led the MEAC in rushing, averaging 104.4 yards per game (,) on 195 attempts with eight touchdowns. He earned the conference’s Offensive Player of the Week accolades three times and Rookie of the Week honors twice this season. A native of Bunn, North Carolina, Cohen became the first freshman in North Carolina A&T State history to rush for over 1,000 yards in a season. Cohen’s is currently listed on the Sports Network’s Jerry Rice Award watch list, which recognizes the nation’s top FCS freshman. Cohen is just the second Aggie to be named Rookie of the Year. He joins the school’s all-time rushing leader, Mike Mayhew, who earned the honor in 2009.
Tristan Bellamy aided a dominating Bulldog offense that accounted for 4,101 yards of total offense , including 2,000 yards on the ground. Behind Bellamy’s blocking S.C. State finished second in the MEAC in scoring offense (29.6 ppg), and third in total offense (341.1 avg./g). Bellamy earned the conference’s Offensive Lineman of the Week honor twice this season. Bellamy is the sixth Bulldog to earn Offensive Lineman of the Year accolades.
South Carolina State led all schools with 13 student-athletes recognized on the three MEAC post-season teams. The Bulldogs have five student-athletes earn first-team honors, in addition to two-of-four top awards.
Bethune-Cookman finished close behind with 12 student-athletes to earn post–season honors, in addition to five first-team selections.
Mid-Eastern Athletic Conference (MEAC) – 2013 Football All-Conference Teams
Offensive Player of the Year: Greg McGhee, Howard
Defensive Player of the Year: Joe Thomas, South Carolina State
Offensive Lineman of the Year: Tristan Bellamy, South Carolina State
Rookie of the Year: Tarik Cohen, North Carolina A&T
For the second consecutive year, Bethune-Cookman (10-2) and Coastal Carolina (10-2) will square off in the first round of the FCS playoffs.
The Wildcats, who fell to the Chanticleers 24-14 in Daytona Beach last season, will travel to Brooks Stadium in Conway, S.C. for a 1:00 kickoff according to www.ncaa.com.
The BCU/CCU winner will travel cross-country for a matchup with Montana who received a first-round bye and the tournaments 8th seed.
BCU is one of three HBCU teams headed to the FCS playoffs this season. MEAC Co-Champion, South Carolina State (9-3), and Ohio Valley 2nd place finisher, Tennessee State (9-3), join the Wildcats in the field of twenty-four.
South Carolina State will host their first ever FCS playoff game in a matchup against fellow Palmetto State foe Furman of the Southern Conference while Tennessee State will hit the road for a matchup against Butler (9-3) of the Pioneer League.
The Wildcats own victories over both SCSU and Tenn State this season. All three games involving HBCU squads kickoff on Saturday at 1:00 EST and can be seen on ESPN3.